A lesson conference is a structured
professional conversation, aimed at analysing a lesson
and improving teaching and student learning. It is often
used in the contexts of mentoring and peer-review, and
when conducting learning studies. The approach to lesson
conferencing in this pack employs a notion of professional
conversation, where:
- schools are viewed as learning communities ;
and
- all involved in the professional conversation
are considered potential learners , no matter
how experienced they may be as teachers.
This view of professional
conversation changes the way lesson conferencing is conceived
when conducted as part of mentoring and peer-review. The
learning community model of mentoring contrasts with the
rather top-down 'transmission' model, where the mentor
acts as councillor and expert critical friend, handing
down advice to the mentee. It also contrasts with the 'supervisory'
model of peer review, where the main purpose of observing
a lesson is to provide the reviewer with the evidence upon
which he or she can provide a well informed, 'neutral'
judgement of the merits of the lesson.
The 'learning community'
model accepts that mentors may well provide counselling
support and may have much accumulated wisdom to pass on
to beginning teachers, and that mentors and peer reviewers
have to make informed judgements regarding professional
competence. Nevertheless, when professional conversation
is conceived as a mutually beneficial exchange of ideas,
as in the learning community model, it will usually not
be one-to-one, as in the more traditional approaches to
mentoring and peer-review. Ideally, it will involve a number
of participants, perhaps the mentor or peer reviewer along
with other experienced teachers. Having multiple voices
in the conversation not only safeguards against possible
mentor or peer-reviewer bias; it opens up the conversation
to the possibility of teachers professionally learning
from one another, in exchanging views and negotiating meanings.
All who participate may therefore be viewed as learners,
even as they also possess professional expertise.
Users of the materials will notice, however, that some
of the video clips show examples of one-to-one conversation,
reflecting the widespread use of that practice. In each
case, the exercises that follow the video extracts invite
users to provide the multiple voices that are missing in
the video clips.
Lesson observation and conferencing, from the perspective
of the learning community model, place a particular emphasis
on pupil learning; not simply teacher performance. Indeed,
whether the pupils have learnt anything and whether what
they learnt was worth learning, plus the strategies used
to bring about learning, provide the main basis on which
comments about teacher performance should be made.
Hence, this pack of materials not only covers
generic skills of lesson conferencing, it also aims to
develop skills within the broader context of lesson observation
and professional debate, where the main focus is on enhancing
pupil learning.